I got a job offer and signed it. After reviewing the background check disclosure I was concerned that it stated that they could contact my present employer. I wrote them an email expressing my concerns and told them i would not be able to consent to my current employer being contacted. They rescinded the offer shortly thereafter. I need legal advice on how to secure a settlement for the total compensation that I lost out on due to their actions. See timeline. June 22: I presented a custom strategy and received positive feedbackJune 25: I received the formal written offerJune 26: I signed and accepted the employment agreementJune 27, 10:07am: Hiring manager contacted me about participating in hiring for my direct reportJune 27, 11:25am: I requested reasonable modifications to th
Full Conversation
I got a job offer and signed it. After reviewing the background check disclosure I was concerned that it stated that they could contact my present employer. I wrote them an email expressing my concerns and told them i would not be able to consent to my current employer being contacted. They rescinded the offer shortly thereafter. I need legal advice on how to secure a settlement for the total compensation that I lost out on due to their actions. See timeline. June 22: I presented a custom strategy and received positive feedback June 25: I received the formal written offer June 26: I signed and accepted the employment agreement June 27, 10:07am: Hiring manager contacted me about participating in hiring for my direct report June 27, 11:25am: I requested reasonable modifications to the background check authorization June 27, 2:29pm: The company rescinded my offer citing "organizational priorities"
Hello! My name is Michael, and I'm an attorney ready to help! Your responses matter to me, so I only need a few minutes to review and respond to each of your posts. Did the job offer include any language about it being contingent on a completed background check, and did they ever respond in writing to your request for the modification before rescinding the offer?
Dolan, this is my first time using this service. I have included information regarding my issue below. Can you please respond to my inquiry?
Sure thing! The short answer? If the job offer was clearly accepted and the only reason they pulled it was your refusal to let them contact your current employer, you might have a case because their concerns were just a cover. As far as compensation, you can try, but success depends on proving that the offer was firm and that you reasonably relied on it. In other words, it's a claim potentially for what's called "promissory estoppel" That's the short answer. Here is the long answer: You have some recourse under the legal theory of promissory estoppel. What this means is that if someone made a promise upon which another person detrimentally relied, then the aggrieved party may be entitled to damages. Promissory estoppel usually requires five (5) things: 1. The defendant made a promise that was clear and unambiguous in its terms 2. The promisee relied on the promise. 3. The reliance on the new promise was reasonable and foreseeable. 4. You were injured by the reliance.(Injury can mean financial injury, not just your body 5. Injustice can be avoided only by enforcement of the promise. You may want to consider writing a formal demand letter advising them you want compensation in this case based on the money you lost from other jobs or income as a result.
Hi Dolan, the job offer did include contingency upon background check but once i tried to start the process with the third party, the background check disclosure stated ocntact could be made with the current employer. They did not respond to my request before rescinding the offer. The rescinsion email cited 'updated organizational priorities' but the job is still open and identical to what I applied to.
I'm not sure what I can show for point. no. 4 since that was my only offer at the time
Understood. Even though the offer was contingent on a background check, the company’s refusal to respond to your reasonable request and then rescinding the offer suggests their stated reason may have been a pretext, giving you a claim for promissory estoppel. As far as damages (#4), even without turning down another job, you can still show reliance if you stopped applying elsewhere, made plans around the offer, or took steps toward transitioning employment.
Is this something you can help me with? Can you help send a letter to them seeking a resolution? I've not done this before so not sure what I can do
So I can't personally send a letter only because this chat limits my ability to represent customers, particularly if you're out of state, but there are some options: 1. You can post a job to contractscounsel.com and get bids; 2. You can even use a demand letter stating you want compensation for their issues. https://www.contractscounsel.com/t/document-form-checkout/256 For a small fee, I can review and revise it for you, but you would need to send it yourself. Thanks!
Thanks Dolan. In your experience, do demand letters typically get a response? And do they carry any weight if sent by the individual vs a lawyer?
Sure thing! Yes, they can be very effective and typically they are effective even if you send them yourself. The reason nis that they don't expect you've spoken to a lawyer to understand your rights, it forces them to reconsider their actions and usually leads to a settlement, and it's a way to help you informally (and inexpensively) assert yourself to let them know you are not backing down!
Thank you. Who would you email it to? The HR lead that has been my primary contact, the hiring manager, the head of HR/Chief People Officer, CEO?
So I would email it to the HR lead and the hiring manager, and the CEO. They are 100% likely to take it to their legal team and are likely to offer a settlement.
Thanks. Should I file a claim with the EEOC?
Good question, but no. Unless it's based on something like race, age, gender, religion, or disability, the EEOC wouldn't have jurisdiction.